LatestHincapie set for improved Arsenal deal as Gunners lock down their core

Unai Emery Is The Manager United Need, Which Is Exactly Why They Probably Cannot Have Him

23 October 2026 · Liam Barker · Posted 4 weeks ago

Emery, Howe, Conte Or McKenna: Weighing Up The Men Who Could Follow Michael Carrick

Manchester United have a habit of arriving at the same crossroads every couple of years, and they are standing at it again. Michael Carrick’s position has weakened badly, and the conversation around Old Trafford has quietly moved from whether he can turn things around to who might replace him if he cannot. According to iNews, one of the names that excites people inside the club most is Aston Villa’s Unai Emery.

The context is bleak. United are seven games without a win, and the 4-1 hammering at Como in the Champions League felt like the moment patience snapped for many supporters. The report describes Carrick as on the brink after that night in Italy, and it is difficult to read the mood any other way.

It has not helped that Bruno Fernandes went public after the game. His comments were read as a sign of discontent in the dressing room, and criticism of Carrick’s tactics from the club captain is the kind of thing hierarchies find very hard to ignore. Whatever the intent, it pushed the situation closer to a decision United had hoped they would never have to make.

Why Emery appeals so much

We can see exactly why Emery’s name keeps coming up. Here is a coach with serious pedigree in England and in Europe, and a recent body of work that stands up against almost anything United have achieved over the same period. At Villa he has won the Europa League, delivered two fourth-placed finishes and taken the club to a Champions League quarter-final.

What reportedly impressed observers at United even more was how he handled a summer of upheaval, tearing up and rebuilding a squad while wrestling with financial fair play rules, and still keeping standards high. That is precisely the skill set United have lacked: someone who can absorb disruption, reshape a group and still produce a team with a clear identity.

The problem is equally obvious. People close to Emery insist he is fully committed to Villa. United’s executives may admire him enormously, but admiration and availability are two completely different things. If Carrick goes, interest in Emery would be real. Prising him away from a project he is clearly enjoying would be another matter entirely.

Howe and Conte: the free agents

If United prefer someone they can appoint without paying compensation, Antonio Conte and Eddie Howe are both in the frame. Conte is never short of admirers, and the report suggests the Italian would be keen. His record speaks for itself. His style would also be a dramatic change from Carrick’s more collaborative approach, built on authority and relentless demands.

That is where the doubts creep in. Conte can raise standards quickly, but there are long-standing questions over whether his intensity suits the environment at Old Trafford. Ashley Young has even warned that such an appointment could turn into a disaster, and he knows both the club and the manager well.

Howe is perhaps the more logical option. He is reportedly the bookmakers’ favourite and, in many eyes, the most sensible choice available, having ended Newcastle United’s long wait for a trophy and led them into two Champions League campaigns.

There is an important caveat, though. Howe is said to want the right fit, and that includes a say in recruitment. Any talks would almost certainly involve discussions about how he would work alongside Jason Wilcox. We actually see that as a positive. A manager who asks hard questions about structure before taking the job is far more likely to succeed than one who simply signs on the dotted line.

The outside bets

Kieran McKenna is another candidate understood to be interested. He has a strong reputation for developing players, previous ties to United and, according to the report, numbers that stand out in data analysis, which is increasingly important to modern executives.

Fabian Hurzeler is also on the radar, but the challenge there is obvious. Brighton are flying, and convincing a young coach to leave a stable, rising project for one engulfed in turmoil is a tough sell. It is hard to imagine that pitch landing.

For now, Carrick remains in charge. But the tone of the reporting makes it clear United are studying the market seriously, and that the next step depends on whether they believe the current slide can be stopped or whether another reset is unavoidable.

Our take

We think this is a moment United simply cannot afford to get wrong. There has been too much drift, too much noise and too many fresh starts that led nowhere. Emery being admired internally makes complete sense because he is a builder. He improves players, creates structure and gives his teams a recognisable identity, all things United have been missing.

The trouble is that the very qualities that make Emery ideal also make him unlikely to leave a club where he is thriving. If he really is committed to Villa, United may be describing their dream candidate rather than a realistic one. Even so, the fact his profile is being considered shows the standard the club should be aiming for.

Howe feels more attainable and, in plenty of ways, the more sensible fit. His insistence on the right conditions is encouraging, because United need a manager who sees the bigger picture and demands proper backing on recruitment, structure and accountability above the head coach.

Above all, United need clarity. If Carrick has lost the dressing room, dragging the situation out will only make it worse. If there is a way back, the results need to show it straight away. Supporters can live with difficult spells. What they cannot accept is the absence of a plan, and right now a coach like Emery or Howe looks much closer to one than anything currently on show.