Why United’s long chase of Pochettino says as much about the club as the coach
We have lost count of the number of times Mauricio Pochettino’s name has drifted into conversations about the Manchester United dugout. This time, though, it feels different. The Argentine is now the man United want to take over from Michael Carrick, and by most accounts the two sides are close to an agreement, even though Carrick is still in the job and nothing official has been said about his future.
The detail comes from David Ornstein, Adam Crafton and Laurie Whitwell at The Athletic, who report that talks are at an advanced stage. For a club that has burned through managers at a remarkable rate over the past decade, that is a big moment, and our view is that it deserves more scrutiny than a simple verdict on whether he is the right man.
How Carrick ran out of road
The numbers are brutal. One win from the first ten Premier League games has left United sitting in the relegation places, and a run of just three wins in 15 matches has made Carrick’s position almost impossible to defend. Whatever goodwill he carried as a former midfielder and a club man has been worn away by results.
What troubles us is the way it is being handled. Carrick was out at Carrington taking training on Tuesday while senior figures prepared for talks in Monaco involving Sir Jim Ratcliffe, and while discussions with his likely replacement were moving forward. That is an awkward picture for any dressing room, and it hardly suggests a club that has learned to make these calls cleanly.
We have real sympathy for Carrick. He clearly cares about United, and seeing another former player buckle under the weight of the job is not pleasant to watch. But one league win in ten is simply not acceptable for a club with these resources, and supporters are entitled to expect change.
What Pochettino would bring
There is plenty to like about the idea. At Tottenham Hotspur, Pochettino turned a club on the fringes into a regular top-four side, built around young players and a high-energy, demanding style, and he took them all the way to the 2019 Champions League final. His later spells at Paris Saint-Germain and Chelsea were more of a mixed bag, but both taught him how to handle big personalities inside big institutions, which is hardly irrelevant at Old Trafford.
His work with the United States has strengthened the case. Since taking the job in 2024 he has won 21 of his 35 games, and he led the Americans to the last 16 of the 2026 World Cup before Belgium beat them 4-1. He knows the Premier League, he knows its pressures, and he is reported to be keen on the move, with talks over personal terms said to be going well.
The cost and the catch
The obstacle is money. Pochettino is tied to the US until 2030, and prising him away could mean a compensation payment in the region of £7.4m, plus further fees to bring his backroom staff with him. For a club that has already spent heavily on changing managers, that is another bill to swallow.
There is also a sense of history here. United have been circling Pochettino on and off since 2016, when Sir Alex Ferguson made no secret of how highly he rated him, and the timing never quite worked. It has taken a genuine crisis to finally bring the two together, which is not the ideal backdrop for any appointment.
Our take
We think Pochettino would be an exciting choice, and fans would welcome him warmly. His first jobs would be obvious ones: restore some belief, give the team a clear identity, and squeeze far more consistency out of a squad that is underperforming badly. Staying up comes first, rebuilding standards second.
But we have watched enough new managers walk through the door at Old Trafford to know that the name in the dugout is only half the story. INEOS, Jason Wilcox and the rest of the football leadership need to prove that recruitment, coaching and long-term planning are finally pulling in the same direction. If they give Pochettino a proper runway and stop the constant noise about his future, this could work. If not, United will be having this same conversation again before long.