Collins, Robinson, Bassey and Balogun: the logic behind United’s January plans
Mauricio Pochettino is still preparing to formally start work at Old Trafford, yet Manchester United’s January planning is already taking shape around him. According to talkSPORT, the club have put together a group of targets weighted heavily towards defence, with Monaco striker Folarin Balogun also being considered as they weigh up the forward line.
The message is that United want to back their new head coach straight away, and the early signs are that the back line is where the money will go first. A disappointing league position has sharpened minds, and there seems to be acceptance inside the club that this window is about practical fixes rather than headline-grabbing luxuries.
Familiar faces for a new coach
Four names lead the list: Brentford’s Nathan Collins, the Fulham pair Calvin Bassey and Antonee Robinson, and Balogun. Chelsea full-back Malo Gusto has also been mentioned in recent days. Two of those players, Robinson and Balogun, worked under Pochettino with the United States national team, and that shared history is unlikely to be a coincidence.
New managers tend to lean on players they already trust, especially in a winter window where prices can be inflated and there is little time for adaptation. Robinson would solve the left-back question, Collins and Bassey would add depth and steel in the middle of defence, and Balogun feeds into a wider debate about Joshua Zirkzee’s future and United’s need for a more reliable presence up front.
A list built around specific problems
What strikes us most is how targeted this feels. Collins has grown into a dependable Premier League centre-back, Bassey brings versatility and physicality, and Robinson offers pace and a direct outlet down the left. Balogun is a different sort of signing, a mobile forward with a poacher’s instinct who would suit a high-energy pressing system.
United’s decision makers are said to want at least one central defender and a new left-back, which matches what supporters have been watching week after week. The defence has looked fragile and disorganised, and the squad cannot afford another half season of the same structural problems. Accuracy in the market matters far more than volume.
Our take on the shortlist
For once, a Manchester United shortlist reads like it was built with a coherent plan. Targeting players who know the league, can cope with its intensity and would not need months to bed in is the kind of thinking the club have often lacked in recent windows.
Robinson is the standout for us. United have needed recovery speed, energy and consistency in the full-back areas for some time, and he ticks all three boxes. Collins would also make sense, particularly if Pochettino wants a calm, reliable presence rather than simply another body. Bassey is a slightly harder sell, but his athletic qualities are obvious.
Balogun is the wildcard. The talent is not in doubt, but whether he arrives depends on how Pochettino sees the attack evolving and whether United are quietly preparing for a change at centre-forward. If Zirkzee’s future remains unresolved, a striker who already knows the coach and is hungry to prove himself in England has real appeal.
Why this window matters so much
Pochettino’s first weeks will be judged on results, but the window will also show whether club and coach are pulling in the same direction. United do not need a flashy January. They need a clever one. If they can land the profiles he wants and do it decisively, this could be the first genuine step towards repairing a season that has gone badly wrong.
There is a bigger picture here too. Every new United manager in recent years has been promised backing, and too often the result has been a scattergun collection of signings that never fitted together. If this list genuinely reflects Pochettino’s wishes, it is a welcome sign that the club are finally listening to the person in the dugout.