£155m spent, three regrets admitted: Manchester United’s recruitment problem is back
It is only October, and Manchester United are already reckoning with their summer business. According to the Daily Star, senior figures at Old Trafford accept there were three clear mistakes in the last window, despite £155m being committed to a midfield rebuild. For a club that has spent so much, so often, that is a grim admission to be making this early.
The thrust of the report is that Andrey Santos and Youri Tielemans were not the players United really wanted, and that the failure to bring in a new left-back is causing frustration. Put simply, United paid big money without landing the profiles at the top of their list.
The results are making the problem impossible to hide
None of this would sting quite as much if the team were winning. The draw with Tottenham left Michael Carrick’s side on six points from six league games, the club’s worst start in four decades. With Champions League football to juggle as well, the lack of depth is already showing.
Look at the total spend and the picture becomes even more uncomfortable. Santos, Tielemans and Carlos Baleba cost a combined £155m, and that came on top of the £225.2m invested the year before in Bryan Mbeumo, Matheus Cunha and Benjamin Sesko. That is a vast outlay over two summers, and the return so far has been modest.
Tielemans has at least been a regular, featuring in all eight matches this season. Santos is another story. The £50m arrival has played just 16 minutes since starting the opening day defeat at Hull City. When a club is privately questioning its own recruitment, numbers like that tend to confirm the worst.
Plan A never seems to happen
The Daily Star says United had Elliot Anderson, Mateus Fernandes, Aurelien Tchouameni and Ederson ranked above Santos and Tielemans. Ederson appears to be the one that hurts most, with a move reportedly collapsing over medical issues. Whatever the reasons, the pattern is familiar: the plan identifies one player and the club ends up somewhere else.
Left-back is even simpler. Luke Shaw has needed proper cover for a long time, and it never arrived. Links with Lewis Hall count for nothing if a deal never gets going. Weaknesses left unaddressed in August have a way of resurfacing every few weeks once the season starts.
Jamie Redknapp was scathing after the Spurs game, saying he saw no connections in the midfield, no confidence and no clear patterns of play, and suggesting Carrick needs more help from above because the squad simply is not strong enough. Harsh, perhaps, but difficult to dispute on the evidence.
Our take
What frustrates us most is how believable all of this sounds. Every club gets signings wrong. The worry is that United’s errors were visible before the leaves had even started to fall.
If the people in charge knew Santos and Tielemans were fallback options, supporters are entitled to ask why the club keeps ending up here. Fans can tolerate a plan that fails. What they struggle with is paying elite fees for compromise signings and then acting surprised when the side still looks unbalanced.
The left-back gap is the clearest example. Everyone could see it. When it stays open, that points to poor planning, poor execution or both, and neither reflects well on the decision makers.
Carrick will take criticism for performances, and some of it will be fair. But a coach needs tools that fit, and right now the midfield lacks legs, the structure looks shaky and the depth is thin. That is not purely a coaching issue.
United fans have watched this loop for years: huge spending, muddled recruitment, early season panic. Admitting regret behind closed doors only matters if it leads to sharper thinking next time. Otherwise it is just another very expensive confession, and the January window will become the next chance to repeat the same mistakes under even more pressure. The club needs a clear list, a clear budget and the discipline to stick to both.