LatestHincapie set for improved Arsenal deal as Gunners lock down their core

Lisandro Martinez points the finger upstairs after United are outclassed in Madrid

14 October 2026 · Liam Barker · Posted 1 month ago

Martinez’s outburst in Madrid says more about Manchester United than the defeat itself

Some defeats are forgotten by the weekend. Others pull back the curtain and show everyone what is going on behind it. Manchester United’s 2-0 loss to Atletico Madrid belongs in the second category, and not only because of what happened on the pitch.

The result stretched United’s winless run to five games in all competitions. What turned it into a major story was Lisandro Martinez. The Argentine has never been one for bland post-match clichés, and his comments afterwards were aimed squarely above the dressing room, at the people responsible for building the squad.

We think his words deserve to be taken seriously, even if the timing was raw.

Martinez goes after the recruitment

Martinez did not mince words. He described the performance as “really poor” more than once, admitted he was having to control himself, and suggested that the display was a reflection of where the club currently is. He pointed out that United had a strong campaign last season and said the players now expected more from the people upstairs in terms of new signings, especially as so many rivals have strengthened.

He was also gracious about the opposition, saying Atletico have a superb side and deserved to win. Then he went further. Martinez said he expected more investment, and that he expected more from technical director Jason Wilcox. He was careful to accept that the players have to do more themselves, but insisted that a strong squad needs to be built to cope with nights like this.

There is no room for misreading that. This was a senior player looking beyond the touchline and straight into the boardroom. He was not dodging responsibility. He was asking whether the recruitment has given this group the balance and resilience it needs.

That is a fair question. United spent around £155m on midfield alone in the summer, bringing in Carlos Baleba, Andrey Santos and Youri Tielemans. The money was serious. Whether it was spent coherently, on the right problems, is another matter entirely.

We would go further. Three midfielders arriving in one window should have given United more control in games like this, not less. Instead, they were overrun in the opening minute and rarely looked comfortable in possession afterwards. That is the gap between spending money and building a team, and it is the gap Martinez was pointing at when he spoke so bluntly.

Atletico expose the same old flaws

Atletico wasted no time. Inside the first minute, Alex Baena picked his moment and slid the ball across for Pablo Barrios to finish. It was quick, direct and ruthlessly simple, and United were behind before they had found their feet.

To be fair, there were chances to respond. Bruno Fernandes struck the crossbar, Julian Alvarez hit the post for the hosts after the break, and Michael Carrick later counted four clear openings that could have changed the night. Johnny Cardoso had a goal chalked off for handball after a VAR check, which gave United a brief reprieve.

They did not take it. Leny Yoro was then sent off after another VAR review for a last-man foul on Jonathan David, and the task became far harder. In the 79th minute, David forced Senne Lammens into a save and Ademola Lookman swept in the rebound.

The overriding feeling was of a team drifting. United had decent spells without authority, possession without menace and effort without enough cutting edge. Atletico looked like a side that understood the occasion. United looked like a team still trying to convince itself that it belonged at this level.

Carrick under the spotlight again

Pressure follows whoever sits in the United dugout, and Carrick is now feeling it. He said afterwards that his side had four really good chances, that the red card was a poor decision which went against them, and that it was difficult after that. He also admitted United were disappointed not to create more.

He has a point about the fine margins. Take one chance, avoid one red card, and the story changes. But elite football is also about imposing yourself often enough that a single setback does not empty your entire evening. United never managed that.

Interestingly, Martinez did not blame the manager. Asked whether a change in the dugout would solve things, he said he did not think so and that Carrick does his best. His argument was that every season is different, opponents learn how you play, and clubs that keep changing managers rather than looking at other areas end up with a big problem. He added that it is easy to blame the coach or the players, but other parts of the club need examining too.

At a club where the manager has so often been the shield for deeper failings, that is an uncomfortable message to hear.

Our take

In our view, Martinez has said out loud what a lot of United supporters were already thinking. The spending has been huge, but the squad still looks short of balance, depth and leadership. When a player of his standing feels compelled to speak like this, it tells you the frustration inside the camp is real.

Carrick tried to cool things down, saying he had not seen the comments, that emotions run high after a defeat like this and that it was not the right time for him to respond. He stressed that everyone cares, shows it in different ways, and that the priority now is sticking together ahead of the trip to Leeds United.

Togetherness is the word managers reach for when a club starts to shake. United need more than that. They need clarity, sharper decision making in the recruitment department and a level of conviction that has been missing for too long.

The danger is that the club treats this as a discipline issue and moves on without addressing the substance. That would be a mistake. Martinez may have chosen a raw moment to speak, but the questions he raised about investment, planning and leadership are not going away.

For now, Manchester United look like a club still searching for an answer to the most basic question of all: has enough been done upstairs to give this team a real platform to compete? On this evidence, the honest answer is no.