LatestHincapie set for improved Arsenal deal as Gunners lock down their core

Martinez exit edges closer as Manchester United plan defensive overhaul

21 October 2026 · Liam Barker · Posted 4 weeks ago

Lisandro Martinez set for summer sale in latest Old Trafford reshuffle

Manchester United’s defence is heading for another summer of upheaval, and Lisandro Martinez looks increasingly likely to be one of the casualties. According to the Daily Mail, the feeling inside Old Trafford is that a wide-ranging rebuild at the back will accelerate once the season ends, and the Argentine is near the top of the list of players who could be moved on.

Our first reaction? This is a decision that has been coming for a while, and frankly it is the right one if handled properly.

Why Martinez is suddenly vulnerable

The easy assumption would be that this is fallout from his outspoken comments about United’s summer recruitment. Those remarks certainly caused a stir, led to disciplinary action and were followed by an apology. But the report is clear that the public criticism is not the main driver here.

The real issue is the contract. Martinez’s current deal is due to expire at the end of June, and United have no intention of watching a player of his status walk away for free. The logical route is to activate the one-year extension option and then look to sell next summer, protecting his value in the process.

That is cold, practical squad management, and we have no problem with it. Since his £57m move from Ajax in 2022, Martinez has been a fixture on the left of central defence whenever fit, and when he plays he brings aggression, quality on the ball and real leadership. The trouble is the phrase whenever fit. His latest thigh problem, picked up at Elland Road, was another reminder of how much football he has missed during his time in Manchester.

The bigger picture at the back

Martinez is only one piece of the puzzle. Luke Shaw is closing in on the end of his contract after more than ten years at the club, and Harry Maguire’s deal includes an extension option that has yet to be decided. That means three senior defenders with question marks over their futures at the same time, which is either an opportunity for a proper reset or a recipe for chaos, depending on how well the club plans.

That helps explain why Jarrad Branthwaite has never really gone away as a target. United had bids worth up to £50m knocked back by Everton in 2024, and the interest has not cooled. A left-sided centre-back with Premier League experience who is still young enough to improve is exactly the profile United need if Martinez departs.

There is at least one area of certainty. Matthijs de Ligt, despite a frustrating spell that included back surgery and a lengthy absence, is not part of the conversation about departures. United see him as a long-term piece of the squad, and his contract running until 2029 backs that up.

No panic over Carrick, and an exit route for Amass

The report also tried to calm some of the noise around the leadership. Talk of a crisis meeting between Michael Carrick and Jason Wilcox at Carrington on Monday was apparently inaccurate, with no such summit taking place.

That is worth noting given the backdrop. United are six matches without a win, Carrick’s league start has been difficult, and Wilcox has faced questions since Martinez went public. Even so, Sir Jim Ratcliffe is understood to still back Wilcox, and there is said to be no appetite to change the head coach at this point.

We find that refreshing, even if plenty of supporters will not. United have spent years lurching from one reactive decision to the next. Preparing for changes in personnel while resisting knee-jerk upheaval in the dugout is at least a sign of a calmer approach.

Another storyline to follow is Harry Amass. The 19-year-old is widely expected to leave in January after getting very few chances this season. What makes it striking is that, even with injuries at left-back, players from other positions have been chosen ahead of him.

When that happens, the message is pretty clear. United were open to moving him on in the summer and may now revisit that, either on loan or permanently, with a number of Championship sides said to be keen. Having already benefited from senior football at Sheffield Wednesday, he would gain nothing from another six months on the bench.

Our take

All of this feels very familiar to anyone who has followed United in recent years. Contracts running down, injuries dictating decisions, and yet another summer in which the back line needs serious work. It is a cycle the club has struggled to break.

Martinez has been a fantastic character, full of fight, and nobody doubts his commitment. But United cannot keep building around players who spend so long in the treatment room, no matter how popular they are with the fans. Taking up the option and selling would be sensible. Letting him leave for nothing would be careless, and the same applies to the decisions on Shaw and Maguire. Sentiment has influenced too many choices at this club for too long.

On Branthwaite, our advice is simple. If United believe he is the answer, they should move decisively. We have all seen what happens when they hover over a target for months: the price climbs, the saga drags on and the club ends up looking indecisive. If he is not the one, identify an alternative quickly and act like a well-run organisation.

As for Amass, if he cannot get a game during an injury crisis, he needs to go and play somewhere that values him. Young players do not develop sitting on the bench. Right now, any evidence of joined-up planning, in recruitment or in player development, would be very welcome at Old Trafford.