LatestHincapie set for improved Arsenal deal as Gunners lock down their core

Martinez says sorry and takes a fine, but United’s real problems have not gone anywhere

16 October 2026 · Liam Barker · Posted 1 month ago

A fine, an apology and an unanswered contract question for Lisandro Martinez

Lisandro Martinez has been fined by Manchester United and has publicly apologised for his criticism of the club’s hierarchy. On paper, that closes the chapter. In reality, we do not think it changes much at all, either about the mood around Old Trafford or about the defender’s own future.

The Argentine was furious after the Champions League defeat to Atletico Madrid, arguing that Michael Carrick had been handed a squad lacking quality and depth. He said he wanted more investment and expected more from technical director Jason Wilcox. Clubs rarely let comments like that slide, least of all when results are already poor.

The climbdown

After meeting senior figures and the manager on Thursday, Martinez moved quickly to calm things down. In a statement, he described the talks as very positive and said both sides were able to speak openly about what had happened after the game. He called himself a passionate person who lives football intensely, and admitted that the frustration of the defeat led him to say what he felt at a time and place that were not right, before apologising.

He went on to say the club is at its best when everyone is united, accepted that his words had not helped with that, and insisted that every person at United is working towards the same goal of bringing success to the club and its fans. With the matter behind him, he said, the focus is now on winning together.

It is a sensible response, and probably the only realistic one available to him.

Why the timing makes it worse

Context is everything here. Carrick’s side sit 13th in the Premier League with six points from six games, and they have won just two of nine matches in all competitions. A senior player speaking out in that situation exposes more than one man’s frustration. It suggests confidence is brittle and patience is wearing thin.

Martinez later softened his tone further, saying he had spoken out of anger and that he still believes in his teammates, his manager and everyone trying to move the club forward. Fine. But the original comments landed precisely because they reflected a wider feeling of drift that many supporters share.

The bigger issue is his contract

There is another matter that may prove more significant than the fine. Martinez is out of contract at the end of the season, although United hold an option to extend it by 12 months. As yet, the club has not decided whether to take it up.

So the apology resolves a disciplinary issue while leaving the bigger football decision untouched. Whether Carrick selects him for the trip to Leeds United is one question. Whether United still see him as part of their medium-term plans is quite another.

Our take is simple. At a stable club, this would be a minor irritation. At Manchester United, it becomes part of a pattern: mediocre results, lingering doubts over how the squad was built, and now one of the team’s most vocal leaders forced to walk back his criticism. Problem solved? Hardly. It is just the latest reminder that United still have too many issues and far too little clarity.