LatestHincapie set for improved Arsenal deal as Gunners lock down their core

Kaoru Mitoma contract stalemate puts Brighton on the clock

10 September 2026 · Callum Reid · Posted 2 months ago

Brighton risk losing control of the Kaoru Mitoma situation

Of all the contract situations Brighton could have wanted to drift, Kaoru Mitoma’s would have been close to the bottom of the list. Yet that appears to be exactly what is happening. TeamTalk report that negotiations over a new deal have ground to a halt, that optimism inside the club has cooled, and that a January departure is now a realistic scenario.

We think this is one of the more significant stories at the Amex this autumn, because Mitoma is not simply a good player on a rolling deal. He is one of the faces of the modern Brighton.

How the clock started ticking

Rewind to October 2023 and the four-year extension Mitoma signed looked like typical Brighton foresight. It tied down a winger who had burst onto the scene, and it put him on wages reported to be around £80,000 a week, a clear sign of how highly he was rated. That deal runs to 30 June 2027.

Fast forward to now and the arithmetic has changed. With well under a year left to run, the club’s grip is loosening. By January he will be within six months of the end of his deal and free to talk to clubs abroad. Every month that passes without a signature chips away at the fee Brighton can command.

Back in March, Fabian Hürzeler sounded relaxed. He spoke of talks continuing, of the player being fully committed and of that commitment showing up in training and in matches. It was the kind of calm public line any head coach would give. The problem is that the private picture seems to have moved on.

The sticking point

The key detail in the report is that progress has stalled because Mitoma is wary of committing while so many clubs are watching him. That is a perfectly understandable stance from a player’s point of view. Interest gives him options, and options give him power.

For Brighton, that is the uncomfortable part. Once a player believes his next move could be bigger than staying, there is only so much a club can do to change his mind. Money helps, a clear sporting project helps, but the leverage tilts towards the player and his representatives.

That leaves the club staring at two unpleasant routes if nothing shifts: a reduced-fee sale in the winter, or the worst case of watching him leave on a free once his contract expires.

Fitness is the wildcard

There is another layer to this. Mitoma suffered a hamstring problem in May that ended his 2025-26 campaign early and cost him a place at the World Cup. He is not expected back until around mid-October. That matters in two directions.

On one hand, a long absence could cool some of the outside interest, particularly from clubs nervous about his injury record. On the other, a strong return could reignite it and push his value straight back up. Brighton will be hoping the latter happens and that a fit, firing Mitoma is more open to fresh talks.

Since arriving from Kawasaki Frontale in 2021, his best football has been thrilling. Few wingers in the league are as comfortable running at a full-back one on one, and his acceleration over the first few yards changes games. When he is on form, Brighton’s attack simply looks different.

Our take

We do not think Brighton fans need to panic just yet, but this is a situation that needs gripping. The club’s track record suggests it will not be bullied into a bad deal. Jan-Paul van Hecke was sold to Tottenham Hotspur with only twelve months left on his contract, and Brighton still banked a healthy fee. That precedent should give supporters some comfort that even an exit would not necessarily mean a giveaway.

Still, Mitoma is a different case. He is a player people buy tickets to watch, and his departure would land harder than most. The report’s suggestion of an emotional split feels about right.

The bigger worry for us is the wider picture on the flanks. The same reporting suggests Liverpool are still tracking Yankuba Minteh. If both wingers end up in play at the same time, Brighton could be forced into a major rebuild of their attack within the space of a few months, something no head coach would welcome mid-season.

What Brighton cannot afford is indecision. Either they find a way to convince Mitoma that his future is best served on the south coast, or they plan a sale that delivers proper value and a ready-made replacement. Letting it drift into next summer would be the one outcome that undermines the clever, proactive reputation the club has spent years building. January now looks like the month where this story will be decided, one way or another.