The Gremio defender who could solve Everton’s long-term back-line puzzle
Every so often a transfer link lands that makes immediate sense, and we think Everton’s reported interest in Gustavo Martins is one of them. Hard Tackle reports that the Gremio centre-back is a genuine target for the Toffees ahead of January, and that Nottingham Forest are circling too. For a club that has spent too long plugging holes rather than planning ahead, this is the kind of name we want to see on the list.
Why Everton cannot keep putting this off
Look at the current centre-back picture at Everton and the problem is obvious. James Tarkowski and Michael Keane have both passed 30. Neither is finished, and Tarkowski in particular still brings leadership and bite, but nobody at the club should be pretending either man is the answer for the next five years.
Then there is Jarrad Branthwaite. Interest in him has never really gone away, and every window seems to bring a fresh round of speculation about bigger clubs testing Everton’s resolve. Whether he stays or goes, the smart move is to have a successor identified before anyone is forced into a panic. That, in our view, is where Martins fits. Everton have also been connected with Vitao, which suggests the recruitment staff know exactly which area of the squad needs work.
What Martins would actually bring
Martins is 24 and came through at Vasco da Gama before joining Gremio in 2019. He has racked up 129 appearances for the Porto Alegre club, chipping in with 13 goals and two assists, a healthy return for a centre-back. Gremio have endured a difficult 2026, yet he has still been one of their more dependable performers, playing 40 times this year and scoring four.
Physically, he looks built for England. He stands 1.91m tall, and the scouting picture points to a player who is quick across the ground as well as strong in the air. That combination matters. Plenty of big centre-backs arrive in the Premier League and look fine until a forward runs at them in space. Mobility is what tends to separate the ones who last from the ones who get found out.
He is also right-footed, which would give Everton natural balance alongside a left-sided partner, and at his age there is still plenty of room for growth.
The price is right, the risk is real
Gremio are said to want somewhere between €12m and €15m. In a market where fairly ordinary Premier League defenders routinely go for far more, we think that is a sensible figure for a player with this level of senior experience. There is even a resale argument if he develops the way his profile suggests he could.
The worry, and it is a fair one, is adaptation. A mid-season move from South America is never simple. The tempo, the physical demands and the sheer scrutiny of the Premier League have caught out talented Brazilian defenders before, and Everton are not in a position to carry a signing who needs a year and a half to settle. That risk has to be weighed honestly.
Forest’s involvement adds another layer. They have shown they can move quickly for value players, and the suggestion is that Martins is ready to make the jump to England in January. If Everton want him, hesitation could cost them.
Our take
We like this one. It is not a glamour signing and it will not sell season tickets, but it addresses a real need at a fee that will not cripple David Moyes’ budget. Everton have spent too many windows reacting rather than planning. Identifying a young, athletic centre-back before Branthwaite’s situation comes to a head, and before Tarkowski starts to slow down, is exactly what a well-run club should be doing.
If Everton are serious about competing with sides like Forest for players of this type, this is a deal they should be winning. Do the homework, agree the fee and get it done.