Balogun and Freeman: the familiar faces who could define Manchester United’s winter
Every new manager arrives with a contacts book, and if the latest reporting is right, Mauricio Pochettino’s could be open on the desk at Carrington before he has even unpacked. TeamTalk say Manchester United are weighing up a January move for two United States internationals, Folarin Balogun and Alex Freeman, and that the expected change in the dugout is a big reason why both names have climbed the list.
We think that is the most interesting part of the story. This is not a club throwing darts at a transfer board. It looks like a club shaping its shopping around the man who will have to coach whoever arrives, and for United that would be a welcome change of habit.
Why Balogun suddenly makes sense
Start with the striker. Balogun has had a rough time at Monaco, where he has slipped down the pecking order, and the word coming out of his camp is that he would like a route back to English football. The former Arsenal forward was reportedly offered to United some time ago as an answer to their lack of goals, but the noise around him has grown since Pochettino emerged as the likely next boss.
That is no coincidence. The two worked together with the USMNT, and Balogun produced some of the best football of his recent career under Pochettino’s guidance. According to the report, his representatives have even suggested that the prospect of playing for his old national team coach makes Old Trafford “somewhat” more attractive. One word, but it tells you plenty. Balogun was not ruling United out before. Now there is a personal pull as well as a professional one.
Monaco, for their part, appear ready to deal. TeamTalk understand the French club would be happy to sell in January, with a permanent transfer their first choice, though a loan carrying the right terms has not been dismissed. For a club like United, who rarely enjoy leverage in the middle of a season, a willing seller is half the battle won.
So the pieces are there. A player who wants to come, a club that wants to let him go, and a coach who already knows how to get the best out of him. On paper, that is about as tidy as a winter deal gets.
Freeman the quieter, smarter option
The second name is less glamorous but, in our eyes, possibly the better bit of business. Alex Freeman has been on United’s radar at Villarreal, and once again the Pochettino link is the thread running through it. The coach gave the young right-back his first proper international chance in the build-up to the World Cup, and Freeman grabbed it, going on to become a regular starter for his country.
That sort of history carries weight. A defender who has already been trusted by his manager at the highest level should settle faster than a stranger, and he is the type of signing that rarely gets the front pages. Young, still improving, and arriving without a huge reputation to live up to, Freeman fits a longer-term plan rather than a panic buy. United have not always been good at telling those apart.
A manager with a real say in recruitment
Perhaps the bigger takeaway is what all this says about how United intend to operate. The report claims Pochettino will be given a much stronger voice in transfer decisions than Michael Carrick had, and if that proves true, Balogun and Freeman could be the first examples of a new way of doing things in Manchester.
There is a case for that. For years, United have looked like a club pulling in several directions at once, with recruitment, coaching and the boardroom rarely singing from the same sheet. Under INEOS the promise was a joined-up structure. Letting the head coach shape the January list around players he has worked with is one way of getting there, as long as it does not tip over into a manager simply buying his favourites.
That balance is where things can go wrong. Plenty of managers have arrived at big clubs, leant heavily on old relationships and left behind a squad stuffed with players who only ever made sense to one person. United will need their recruitment staff to test every one of these ideas properly, not just nod them through because the new boss likes them.
Our take on United’s January direction
We like the logic, but we would split these two targets very differently. Freeman feels like a sensible, low-risk move with a clear upside. He fills a position that needs depth, he knows what his coach expects, and he should improve with time. If United can get him at a reasonable price, it is hard to see much of a downside.
Balogun is a far bigger gamble. There is talent there and there is evidence that he responds to Pochettino, but a forward who has fallen out of favour in Ligue 1 is not an obvious fix for a club with Champions League ambitions. United supporters have heard the “fresh start will revive him” argument many times, and too often it has ended in an expensive shrug. If the striker comes, it has to be on terms that protect the club if it does not work, and a loan with an option might be the smartest route.
What we do find encouraging is the sense of a plan. Both of these players have a clear role, both have a link to the man picking the team, and neither looks like a vanity signing. If that is the template for the Pochettino era, United fans might finally see a window where the pieces fit together, rather than another month of chasing headlines. January will tell us whether the club have learned anything.