LatestHincapie set for improved Arsenal deal as Gunners lock down their core

Emery, Howe and Nagelsmann named as Manchester United weigh Carrick succession

22 October 2026 · Liam Barker · Posted 4 weeks ago

Manchester United’s crowded shortlist reveals a club unsure of its next step

There is an old rule in football that the louder a club insists its manager is safe, the busier its recruitment staff are behind the scenes. Manchester United appear to be following that script to the letter. Michael Carrick still has the job and the official message is one of support, but a report from TEAMtalk suggests the list of possible successors is already long, varied and, in our view, a little confused.

Unai Emery is said to be firmly on that shortlist. So are Eddie Howe and Julian Nagelsmann, with Antonio Conte also in the conversation. Each would represent a completely different kind of reset, and that tells us more about United’s current state of mind than any public statement could.

The Emery problem

Let us start with the most eye-catching name. Emery makes obvious sense on paper. He is meticulous, vastly experienced and has turned Aston Villa into a well-drilled, ambitious side capable of competing with the best. United have reportedly looked into his background before, so this is not a name plucked out of thin air after one bad result. It appears to be part of a longer-term succession plan.

The issue is not whether United like him. It is whether they could ever get him. Emery is under contract at Villa until 2029, and Villa are not a club that sees itself as a stepping stone. They have no reason to do United any favours, least of all in the middle of a season. Prising an established manager away from a stable Premier League rival is expensive, slow and politically awkward, and United seem to know that.

Which is why the report suggests the club are also weighing up alternatives with fewer obstacles. Admiration is one thing. Availability is quite another. If things get worse quickly and United feel forced to act, they are far more likely to turn to someone who could walk through the door tomorrow.

Howe, Nagelsmann and Conte: three very different paths

That is where the shortlist gets genuinely interesting. Howe and Nagelsmann are both out of work and both are believed to have backers inside Old Trafford.

Howe’s case is straightforward. He knows the Premier League inside out, he has coped with intense pressure, and he has shown he can rebuild a club’s culture and lift standards over a period of years. Jason Wilcox is reportedly an admirer, and we can see why. In English football, knowing the terrain still counts for a lot, particularly at a club where the job has chewed up so many coaches.

Nagelsmann is the more modern, more speculative option. He is young, tactically progressive and appealing to any club that wants a fresh identity. Christopher Vivell is understood to be pushing his credentials. The obvious question mark is his lack of Premier League experience, and that is not a small concern at a club already short on stability. He looks like a strategic appointment rather than a firefighter.

There is a practical benefit to both men. Because they are free, there is no compensation to negotiate, no awkward stand-off with another club and no lengthy wait. That simplicity matters if United feel time is running out.

Then there is Conte, the emergency lever. Everyone knows what he brings: intensity, confrontation, demands from day one and, usually, a short-term surge in results. If the brief is to shake the dressing room and impose standards overnight, few coaches have a better record. The trade-off is that his tenures rarely last, and his methods are about winning now rather than building patiently.

Fabian Hürzeler and Cesc Fabregas are also admired, according to the report, though both look extremely difficult to extract from their current clubs.

Why the pressure on Carrick is real

None of this would be happening if results were acceptable. United have made their worst league start since 1986, and the 4-1 defeat at Como was another dent to confidence. The report also mentions frustration behind the scenes about senior players who are underperforming and the growing noise around the squad.

When results are bad and big names start making headlines for the wrong reasons away from the pitch, a manager’s margin for error shrinks rapidly. That is the backdrop to the upcoming Bournemouth game. It may not decide Carrick’s future on its own, but it sits in a run of matches now being assessed with real urgency.

The hierarchy are said to be disheartened by how many players are failing to deliver consistently. History tells us that, at clubs in this position, the simplest executive response is usually to change the coach and hope the players react. It is not always the right answer, but it is the most common one.

Our take

What strikes us most is the range of names. Emery, Howe, Nagelsmann, Conte and a nod to younger coaches elsewhere do not add up to one plan. They add up to several competing ideas. Emery means proven elite coaching from inside the league. Howe means domestic know-how and a steady long-term fit. Nagelsmann means a modern rebuild. Conte means immediate force. United seem to know they might need to act, but not yet what problem they are actually trying to solve.

If we had to pick, Howe looks the most sensible fit. He understands the weekly demands of this league and would bring a calm authority that United have often lacked. Emery would be a coup, but we struggle to see Villa letting him go, and United do not need another drawn-out saga. Nagelsmann is exciting in theory, but asking him to learn English football from scratch while steadying a club in crisis feels like a gamble too far.

Conte is the wild card, and we understand the appeal. He would not tolerate passengers and would demand far more from this squad. But that route comes with a shelf life, and if United genuinely want a rebuild, it probably is not the one.

The deeper issue, as ever, is the playing squad. Changing managers over and over loses its effect when the same flaws keep resurfacing. If Carrick goes, that would be understandable given the results. But whoever follows him needs proper backing, real authority and players willing to respond. Otherwise, United will simply be pressing the reset button again, with the same old problems waiting underneath.

For now, Carrick remains in charge, and that is the official line. But when a club starts doing due diligence this broadly, it usually means the countdown has already begun.