LatestHincapie set for improved Arsenal deal as Gunners lock down their core

Manchester United’s managerial merry-go-round is spinning once again

10 November 2026 · Liam Barker · Posted 1 week ago

Carrick on the brink: why United’s next appointment cannot be another panic buy

Here we go again. Barely months after handing Michael Carrick a two-year contract, Manchester United appear ready to show him the door. Standard Sport reports that the former midfielder’s time in the Old Trafford dugout is close to over, with the club expected to act before the trip to Anfield to face Liverpool on 22 November.

It is a remarkable turnaround. Carrick came in earlier this year as a stopgap following Ruben Amorim’s departure, steadied a club that had lost its way and guided them back into the Champions League. That was enough to earn him the job on a longer-term basis. United made that call with their eyes open, based on what they had seen. Now, it seems, they are preparing to undo it.

How did it unravel so quickly?

The numbers are what make this so stark. United spent the whole of the November international break sitting in the Premier League relegation zone. Let that sink in for a moment. This is a club with one of the biggest budgets in world football, a squad assembled at enormous cost, and it is looking up at the teams it is supposed to be swatting aside.

We do not think that can be pinned solely on the head coach. A slump of this scale points to deeper problems, from recruitment to the decision-making above the dressing room. But football rarely deals in nuance when results are this bad, and the man in the technical area is almost always the first to pay.

The usual suspects lining up

Inevitably, the bookmakers have wasted no time. Mauricio Pochettino leads the betting at 6/4, with Julian Nagelsmann next at 5/2 and former Newcastle boss Eddie Howe priced at 3/1. Antonio Conte, Didier Deschamps, Kieran McKenna and Gareth Southgate all feature further down the list, alongside a handful of names that feel more like wishful thinking, from Carlo Ancelotti and Thomas Tuchel to Diego Simeone and even a sentimental return for Ole Gunnar Solskjaer.

Pochettino is the obvious frontrunner for a reason. He knows the league inside out, he has managed under the glare of huge clubs and he is used to working through internal politics. Nagelsmann would bring a big reputation and a modern approach, though asking a fragile group to absorb yet another new philosophy carries real risk. Conte is the shock-therapy option, demanding and intense, but rarely a long-term fit. Howe, meanwhile, would bring a track record of building something steady from a difficult starting point.

The rest of the list is largely noise. Odds boards are designed to generate interest, not to reflect how a recruitment process actually works.

Our take: this has to be about structure, not names

What frustrates us most is how familiar all of this feels. United keep falling into the same loop. Things go wrong, there is a quick fix, there are promises of a new era, and then the whole thing resets a few months later. Carrick did what was asked of him last season and was rewarded for it. If he is now gone before the Liverpool game, that tells you less about him and more about a club that cannot hold its nerve.

The bigger question is not who replaces him, but whether the next man is given a fair chance. United need clarity in their football operation, a coherent plan for the squad and the patience to stick with a direction through a sticky run of results. Without that, it barely matters whether the new face is Pochettino, Nagelsmann or anyone else on the list.

There was a time when United appointed managers to build dynasties. These days, every search seems to begin with damage limitation. A club of this stature should never find itself among the relegation places for weeks on end, and no single appointment will fix that on its own. Until the people above the manager get their own house in order, we fear this conversation will come round again sooner than anyone at Old Trafford would like.