LatestHincapie set for improved Arsenal deal as Gunners lock down their core

Man United 0-1 Man City ratings: Guehi immense as ten men hold firm

13 September 2026 · Hannah Kerr · Posted 2 months ago

Ten-man City win the derby and United waste seventy minutes of advantage

Manchester United will be kicking themselves for a long time over this one. They had a man advantage for more than seventy minutes at Old Trafford, hit the woodwork twice, and still lost the derby 1-0 to a Manchester City side that refused to buckle. Erling Haaland got the winner, but the real heroes in sky blue were the defenders.

Foden’s moment of madness

The game turned after 23 minutes when Phil Foden lashed out at Bruno Fernandes and was shown a straight red. It was a needless loss of control, and it handed United precisely the opening they needed.

To their credit, United took the initiative. City dropped deeper, space opened up, and the home side controlled the ball. They hit the post before the break and again after it, with Marcus Rashford finding good positions time and again. But the final pass, the final shot, the final decision kept going astray. Lots of pressure, not nearly enough quality.

How City stole it

On the hour, United paid for committing bodies forward. City broke, Josko Gvardiol whipped a low ball across the box that took a deflection, and Haaland was waiting at the far post to tap in. That is six goals in four games for him.

The flag went up, and a long VAR check followed. Eventually the goal stood, with Haaland judged onside and Enzo Fernandez, who had stretched for the ball from an offside spot, ruled not to have affected play. United fans will feel hard done by, but the bigger story is that they could not find a way through ten men for so long.

From there, City were superb at managing the game. Marc Guehi was outstanding, reading every danger, with Ruben Dias solid beside him and Gianluigi Donnarumma commanding behind them. Elliot Anderson ran himself into the ground, Antoine Semenyo gave City an outlet, and Haaland held the ball up whenever they needed to breathe. United, by contrast, lacked composure in the final third. Bryan Mbeumo barely got going and Patrick Dorgu had a miserable day.

Enzo Maresca’s side stay perfect and draw level with Arsenal at the top. United have now dropped points in three of their first four league games and sit 13th.

Our ratings

Manchester United

Senne Lammens: 6/10

Diogo Dalot: 4/10

Harry Maguire: 6/10

Lisandro Martinez: 6/10

Patrick Dorgu: 3/10

Youri Tielemans: 6/10

Kobbie Mainoo: 6/10

Bruno Fernandes: 5/10

Bryan Mbeumo: 4/10

Marcus Rashford: 6/10

Matheus Cunha: 5/10

Manchester City

Gianluigi Donnarumma: 8/10

Matheus Nunes: 7/10

Marc Guehi: 9/10

Ruben Dias: 7/10

Josko Gvardiol: 7/10

Elliot Anderson: 8/10

Enzo Fernandez: 7/10

Rayan Cherki: 5/10

Phil Foden: 2/10

Antoine Semenyo: 7/10

Erling Haaland: 8/10

Enzo Maresca: 8/10

Our verdict

This felt like a title-winning type of result for City, and a damning one for United. Winning a derby with ten men takes organisation and nerve, and City showed both. United were given a golden chance and simply did not have the cutting edge to take it. The worry at Old Trafford is that this is becoming a habit rather than a one-off. Possession without penetration has been a theme of their start, and until someone in the final third starts making better decisions, the points will keep slipping away. City, meanwhile, look like a side that knows exactly how to win ugly when it has to.