LatestHincapie set for improved Arsenal deal as Gunners lock down their core

Manchester City verdict could open a costly new front as rivals weigh compensation claims

30 September 2026 · Amy Russell · Posted 2 months ago

Why the real bill for Manchester City may arrive after the sanctions

We have spent so long talking about what Manchester City might lose in the disciplinary room that we have barely stopped to consider what they might owe outside it. Now that the club have been found guilty of breaching Premier League financial rules, the conversation is shifting. Points deductions and fines grab the headlines, but the real sting in this saga could come later, in the form of civil claims from rivals who believe City’s conduct cost them hard cash.

Our take is simple. The sanctions phase is the opening act, not the finale. Once a breach is established, it stops being only a regulatory matter and starts looking like a commercial dispute, and commercial disputes have a habit of multiplying. If one club decides to sue, others will feel obliged to at least explore it. Then come the agents, the former players and possibly the coaching staff who start wondering what bonuses passed them by. Pile those up and you are into nine figures without much effort.

Tottenham Hotspur sit near the front of that queue. Spurs, along with Liverpool, Manchester United and Arsenal, are understood to have formally reserved their position. None of the four has launched an all out legal assault, but none has closed the door either, and several other clubs are thought to be weighing up the same step. Figures around £50m have been floated for what Spurs could chase, and when you look at what missing out on Europe’s elite competition costs, that is not as outlandish as it first sounds.

Why Tottenham’s case could be the cleanest

The logic for clubs is not complicated. If a rival’s breach genuinely distorted the table, then the money lost as a result can be measured. Think prize money, UEFA distributions, matchday income, sponsor bonuses and the broader commercial lift that comes with playing at the very top. The gap between a Champions League season and a Europa League one is vast, and so is the gap between finishing first and second, or fourth and fifth.

That is why we think Tottenham’s angle is particularly interesting. Missing the Champions League in back to back seasons carries a direct, quantifiable cost. It is far easier to put a lost revenue line in front of a judge than to argue about prestige or momentum. If a club can demonstrate that it was denied tens of millions because a competitor enjoyed an unfair edge, the case starts to build itself.

There is a recent example that every lawyer in the game will be citing. Burnley won £35m from Everton after pursuing them over a financial breach tied to the 2021-22 campaign. Everton are appealing, but the principle has been aired: a loss of chance argument can work when the numbers are solid and the chain of harm is easy to follow. Scale that thinking up to the sums at stake in the City case and you understand why boardrooms are paying attention.

European football is now the beating heart of elite club finances. Miss out for one year and it stings. Miss out for several and the damage compounds, with weaker sponsorship renewals, softer matchday revenue and less muscle in the transfer market.

Players and managers may want their slice too

This is where things get messy. Club claims are one thing, but individual claims from players and coaches are a different beast. They are harder to win, yet not unthinkable.

Modern contracts are stuffed with incentives. There are bonuses for Champions League qualification, bonuses for titles, wage rises triggered by European football and appearance payments tied to success. If a player can argue he missed a payment because his club fell short of the top four in a season affected by City’s breaches, the loss is at least identifiable on paper.

Run the maths on a hypothetical and it becomes sobering. A player earning £4m a year with a 25 per cent uplift for Champions League football would be £1m worse off. Multiply that across a squad, then across several seasons and several clubs, and it is obvious why legal firms are already sniffing around. Managers and backroom staff could look at their own deals too, because performance bonuses linked to league position or European qualification are standard right through the division.

Plenty of these claims would fail, of course, either through thin evidence or because the legal bill would dwarf any payout. But the risk is real enough to worry people across the league.

A fight that could outlast everyone’s patience

For the Premier League, this is the nightmare scenario. Even those with no affection for City are not exactly celebrating. The overriding emotion around the game is weariness. This case has dragged on for so long that almost everybody is sick of it, and the prospect of a second chapter that might run even longer fills few people with joy.

Picture it. The sanctions process concludes, or pauses for an appeal, and then the compensation cases begin to land, one at a time. Club after club, season after season, claim after claim. That is how football ends up being decided in courtrooms instead of on grass.

Proving causation will be the big hurdle. The charges do not all carry equal weight, and not every alleged breach had the same sporting impact. A league table hides thousands of variables, from injuries and refereeing calls to failed signings and managerial sackings. Any claimant has to cut through all of that noise and tie a specific financial loss to a specific breach.

Some cases will still be stronger than others. Missing the Champions League by a single place is far easier to frame than arguing that relegation stemmed from a chain of events linked to City across an entire season. Relegated clubs may still be tempted, given how brutal life can be outside the top flight, but their cases look much murkier to us.

That is what feeds the fear of a free for all. Once one settlement is agreed, others may decide to roll the dice, not because every case is strong, but because the potential reward is enormous.

Senior figures at rival clubs seem to grasp that even if City are hammered, the reputational harm to the competition does not vanish. There is relief in some quarters and curiosity in plenty of others, but very little genuine satisfaction. What almost everyone agrees on is that a case of this size hanging over the league for years has been bad for governance, bad for credibility and bad for business.

So here is where we land. City still face a formal sanctions phase, and that could be severe on its own. Yet the bigger financial threat may sit outside the disciplinary process entirely, through civil actions from clubs and individuals who feel they were robbed of money, status and opportunity. If Tottenham and the others push ahead, this story is nowhere near its final chapter.