Old Trafford’s new era starts with a winter window United cannot afford to waste
Manchester United in the relegation zone after ten games. Read that back and it still does not sound real, but that is where the club finds itself, and it explains why things are moving so quickly behind the scenes. With Michael Carrick gone, Mauricio Pochettino is closing in on the job, and the conversation has already jumped beyond the appointment itself to what he will be allowed to do once he walks through the door.
Fabrizio Romano, speaking on his YouTube channel, made it clear that the club and Pochettino are well past the stage of wondering whether this happens. The focus now is on planning, and in particular on the January transfer window, which is only a few weeks away.
A manager who wants a say
The most telling part of Romano’s update was about Pochettino’s personality as a coach. According to the transfer journalist, the early contacts between the Argentine and United already touched on recruitment, with both sides agreeing that dedicated meetings about January would follow very soon. Romano stressed that this is not a coach who is happy to be handed a squad and told to get on with it. Pochettino wants to be in the room when targets are chosen.
We think that is a big deal at United. For years the club has bought players who did not seem to fit the manager in charge, or who arrived for one coach only to be inherited by the next. Having a head coach who insists on a voice in recruitment is not a cure-all, but it at least gives the club a chance of building a squad with a clear identity.
The obvious gaps are not hard to spot. A left-back and a forward look like the priority positions after the last window failed to solve either problem, and Romano expects United to add players in January whoever ends up in the dugout. He was not sure whether that means one, two or three signings, but he was adamant the club will be active, describing it as part of the wider strategy rather than a panic response.
The contract headache nobody can ignore
Incomings are only half the story. A number of senior players are running down their deals, and that leaves the new coach facing some uncomfortable early decisions. Harry Maguire, Luke Shaw, Lisandro Martinez and Bruno Fernandes are all heading towards the final stretch of their current contracts, and in some cases the room for manoeuvre is limited.
Each of those calls carries weight. Fernandes is still the creative heartbeat of the side on his good days. Maguire and Martinez offer experience at the back, while Shaw’s fitness record means any decision on his future is as much about the medical department as it is about ability. Pochettino will need to decide quickly who is central to his plans and who can be moved on, because if January is going to generate funds or free up space, those choices cannot drift into the spring.
His track record suggests he will not be sentimental. He values balance and commitment inside the dressing room, and if he decides certain profiles do not fit, this winter could end up being just as much about departures as arrivals. That would be a serious test for the football leadership under INEOS, who are already facing heavy criticism for how the sporting side of the club has been run.
Anfield first, then the real work
If Pochettino was hoping for a gentle start, the fixture list has other ideas. He is expected to wrap up his duties with the United States national team and walk almost straight into a trip to Liverpool at Anfield on 22 November. Facing Andoni Iraola’s side with a squad low on belief and short on cohesion, and with barely any time on the training ground, is about as tough an opening as you could design.
There is a silver lining, though. Once that game is out of the way, he gets roughly six weeks before the window opens. That is enough time to watch his players closely, work out who can handle his demands and identify which weaknesses need fixing straight away rather than in the summer. In practical terms, those six weeks could shape the entire winter plan.
Romano also pointed out that Pochettino has a strong record of improving the players he already has, highlighting his Tottenham years as proof that he can get a lot out of a squad without constant churn. In other words, United should expect a blend of coaching and recruitment rather than a scorched earth approach.
Our take: no more half measures
For us, this is a reset that should have come a lot sooner. A club of United’s size sitting in the bottom three is an embarrassment, and the squad has looked unbalanced for far too long, with no sign of a joined-up plan connecting the boardroom, the recruitment team and the dugout. If Pochettino genuinely gets to shape the squad, it could finally drag United into a more modern way of working.
There is also enough talent in this group to climb the table quickly with better coaching and a clearer structure. That is why January matters so much. Backing the new man with the right profiles, rather than familiar names or flashy opportunistic deals, could still rescue a season that already looks badly damaged.
The contract situations need to be handled without emotion as well. United have spent years tolerating uncertainty and rewarding inconsistency. If a player is part of the next cycle, tie him down and end the speculation. If he is not, move him on decisively and use the money well.
Above all, accountability has to sit above the manager’s head too. One appointment cannot paper over years of poor planning. But if Pochettino arrives with real authority, sharp recruitment behind him and a willingness to be ruthless, United finally have a route back towards competence. Right now, that alone would feel like a huge step forward.