Former players snubbed and a defence in need of repair: our verdict on United’s week
There are weeks when Manchester United’s problems feel like a single storyline, and there are weeks like this one, when everything seems to go wrong at once. Off the pitch, a charity row involving former players has reopened old wounds. On it, the recruitment team are drawing up defensive targets for January and Michael Carrick is waiting to see whether Luke Shaw can make it back for a trip to Anfield. As the Daily Mail has reported, each of these threads tells us something about where the club stands right now.
A snub that cuts to the heart of the club
The story that should worry United most has nothing to do with tactics. The Association of Former Manchester United Players had planned to hold its big annual dinner in the Manchester Suite at Old Trafford, only to be told at short notice that the room was no longer available. Hotel Football stepped in to host the event, but the damage to goodwill had already been done.
This is not the first time the charity has felt let down. Sir Jim Ratcliffe’s cost-cutting drive previously ended a yearly £40,000 donation to the association, a decision that drew plenty of criticism when it first came to light. Losing the venue on top of that has only deepened the sense that former players are being pushed to the margins.
John Gubba, who works as the association’s filmmaker and publicist, was scathing. He contrasted the lavish treatment of Sir Alex Ferguson with what he sees as the club turning its back on the wider group of ex-players, and said that holding the dinner at the stadium had always made them feel part of the club. Being moved on at the last minute, he added, left “a bitter taste”.
United’s line is that the stadium simply was not available and that the charity will be welcome back in future. That may well be true, but perception matters enormously at a club so proud of its history. Stories like this stick precisely because they feel like a statement about culture rather than a scheduling clash.
Patching the back line in January
On the football side, the shortlist is starting to take shape. Brentford’s Nathan Collins and Fulham’s Calvin Bassey have joined Everton’s Jarrad Branthwaite among the centre-backs under consideration, and it is not hard to see why defence is the priority. United chose to focus on midfield last summer, and with injuries piling up and Matthijs de Ligt only recently back from a long lay-off, that call now looks expensive.
Each target offers something different. Collins is a reliable, physically robust presence who rarely misses games, a quality United have badly lacked. Bassey brings athleticism, recovery speed and the ability to cover more than one position. Branthwaite is arguably the most complete of the three, but prising him away from Everton and David Moyes would cost a serious amount of money.
There is also talk of a striker, although a loan looks the likelier route. United failed to move Joshua Zirkzee on in the summer and did not bring in a partner for Benjamin Sesko, so some reinforcement up front is needed. Still, with limited room to manoeuvre, central defence has to come first.
Shaw’s comeback could not come at a better time
There is one piece of good news. Shaw, who has not played since October 10, is aiming to return for the visit to Liverpool. His absence has exposed how thin United are on the left, with Diogo Dalot covering and Patrick Dorgu still working his way back into contention.
Having a natural left-back available again would steady a defence that has looked shaky for much of the campaign. Anfield, where Andoni Iraola’s side will be eager to make a statement, is about as tough a place as there is to test that, so getting Shaw through training this week becomes a priority. The fixture list offers little breathing space afterwards either, which makes every fit body count.
Our verdict
What strikes us most is how messy it all feels. Ownership decisions, recruitment gaps and fitness worries are colliding at the same moment, and none of them are new. Sending former players away from Old Trafford for a charity dinner is the kind of misstep a club with United’s heritage should never make, whatever the logistical explanation.
As for the transfer targets, Collins and Bassey are sensible options, but sensible is not the same as transformative. The defensive weaknesses were obvious months ago, and trying to fix them in January, a window where proper squad building rarely happens, says plenty about how the summer was handled.
Shaw’s return would be welcome, but we will hold back on celebrating until he strings a run of games together. United need fewer fragile hopes and more firm foundations, and right now they are still short on the latter.